Outtakes Feud: Lively And Baldoni On It Ends With Us

Trend Breaks

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Jan 23, 2025

52 visitor like this post

Share

Outtakes Feud: Lively and Baldoni on It Ends With Us

Okay, so you guys know I'm obsessed with Colleen Hoover books, right? Like, obsessed. I've read It Ends With Us probably five times – don't judge! And then, BAM! This whole kerfuffle with Blake Lively and Emily Baldoni, the author's sister and the film's screenwriter, blows up. Total drama! It was ALL over TikTok, and honestly? I was glued to my phone. Let's dive into this messy, messy drama.

The Spark: A Different Vision?

So, the gist is this: Blake Lively, who's producing the It Ends With Us movie adaptation, apparently had some… creative differences with Emily Baldoni about the screenplay. I mean, we're talking about a book that's intense. Seriously intense. It deals with domestic abuse, toxic relationships, and finding your way back to yourself. It's not exactly a rom-com. There's a lot to unpack, and it seems like Lively and Baldoni didn't see eye-to-eye on how to best portray all that on screen.

I read somewhere that Lively wanted a more nuanced portrayal of the main character, Lily. Like, maybe showing more of her flaws or internal struggles. Maybe adding subplots or scenes that highlight the complexities of abuse dynamics? It made total sense to me, you know? The book is already amazing, but movies can often simplify things. Adding depth would’ve been good.

Baldoni, on the other hand, might have been more focused on sticking closer to the original text. That’s totally understandable too; sometimes adaptations stray too far from the source material, right? It’s a delicate balance. I’ve heard some people say she wanted to protect the integrity of the story, and you gotta respect that.

Honestly, I think both sides had valid points here. It’s tough adapting a beloved book, especially one this intense, and making everyone happy. You've got hardcore fans who are gonna be picky, and then you've got the creative visions of the people involved. It's a recipe for conflict, and sometimes… a full-blown feud.

My Take: Adapting a Beloved Book is HARD.

Remember when I tried to write a fan fiction of The Hunger Games? Yeah, don't ask. It was… a disaster. I completely butchered Peeta's character, and the plot went completely off the rails. I learned the hard way that adapting something you love is WAY harder than it looks. You need to honor the original while making it your own. And when millions of readers have their own interpretations, well, it's basically a minefield.

I totally get why there might be conflicts. It's not just about plot points; it's about capturing the spirit of the book. The emotions, the characters’ motivations – it's everything. And sometimes, two creative minds just don't see eye to eye on how to achieve that. They might have differing ideas about pacing, character development, or even the overall tone of the movie.

The Fallout and What We Can Learn

This whole thing with Lively and Baldoni is a huge reminder that the creative process is messy. It's not all sunshine and rainbows, especially when it comes to highly anticipated adaptations. There's going to be disagreements, clashes of vision. It's the nature of the beast, I think.

The biggest takeaway for me? Adapting a beloved work is hard. It requires compromise, collaboration, and a lot of respect for both the source material and the new medium. As a reader, I hope that the final product will honor the spirit of Colleen Hoover's powerful novel. And, you know, maybe give us some behind-the-scenes gossip later. Because let's be honest, the drama is almost as good as the book itself. 😜